Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба
Two Views on the Yugoslav Ideology in Serbian Music Periodicals Between the Two World Wars
Чланак у часопису (Објављена верзија)
Метаподаци
Приказ свих података о документуАпстракт
Студија испитује однос према идеологији југословенства у српским музичким часописима између два светска рата. Уочено је присуство двају различитих, па и супротних ставова. Док су поједини музичари снажно заступали
идеју интегралног југословенства, други су желели очување дистинктивних
обележја унутар те заједнице. Та је подела кулминирала у случају Јужнословенског певачког савеза у чији састав Хрватски пјевачки савез није ушао.
Тако се у српској музичкој периодици може пратити темељни идеолошки и
политички проблем Краљевине Југославије.
This study explores the relationship between the Yugoslav ideology as
exhibited in Serbian music magazines published between the two world wars.
These are the following journals: Music (1928–1929), Bulletin of the Music Society
„Stanković” (1928–1934, 1938–1941; in January 1931 it was renamed The Musical Gazette), The Sound (1932–1936), Herald of the South Slavic Choral Union
(1935–1936, 1938), Slavic music (1939–1941) and Review of Music (1940). I have
excluded the magazine Musical Gazette (1922) from consideration because I have
already discussed its ideological aspects in an earlier article (2009).
Yugoslav topics in interwar music periodicals are addressed in an ecstatic tone
by the music writers and editors (particularly immediately after the foundation of
the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes); one also observes open dissent and
criticism of undesirable, wasted tendencies. Signs of profound differences with
respect to the fundamental aspect of Yugoslav ideology – i....e. on the question of the
nature and degree of the unity of nations under the auspices of the ideology, appeared
relatively early in these journals. I argue that three elements: open enthusiasm,
criticism/polemic and fundamental differences, constituted a framework within which the Yugoslav ideology was expressed in the Serbian musical periodicals.
The third aspect has proved to be crucial. One could observe two different and
even opposing views on the Yugoslav ideology. While some musicians strongly
advocated integral Yugoslavism, others wanted the preservation of distinctive
national features within this ideology. This division is illustrated by the writings
of Croatian composer and ethnomusicologist Božidar Širola and Serbian composer
and music critic Milenko Živković. The division in question culminated in the
case of the South Slavic Choral Union, which Croatian Choral Union refused to
join. Hence, Serbian music periodicals provide an insight into the fundamental
ideological and political problem of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia.
Кључне речи:
југословенска идеологија / српска музичка периодика – XX век / Јужнословенски певачки савез / Хрватски пјевачки савез / Божидар Широла / Миленко ЖивковићИзвор:
Музикологија / Musicology, 2014, 17, 155-166Издавач:
- Београд : Музиколошки институт Српске академије наука и уметности
Финансирање / пројекти:
- Идентитети српске музике од локалних до глобалних оквира: традиције, промене, изазови (RS-MESTD-Basic Research (BR or ON)-177004)
URI
http://www.doiserbia.nb.rs/img/doi/1450-9814/2014/1450-98141417155V.pdfhttps://dais.sanu.ac.rs/123456789/3871
Колекције
Институција/група
Музиколошки институт САНУ / Institute of Musicology SASATY - JOUR AU - Васић, Александар PY - 2014 UR - http://www.doiserbia.nb.rs/img/doi/1450-9814/2014/1450-98141417155V.pdf UR - https://dais.sanu.ac.rs/123456789/3871 AB - Студија испитује однос према идеологији југословенства у српским музичким часописима између два светска рата. Уочено је присуство двају различитих, па и супротних ставова. Док су поједини музичари снажно заступали идеју интегралног југословенства, други су желели очување дистинктивних обележја унутар те заједнице. Та је подела кулминирала у случају Јужнословенског певачког савеза у чији састав Хрватски пјевачки савез није ушао. Тако се у српској музичкој периодици може пратити темељни идеолошки и политички проблем Краљевине Југославије. AB - This study explores the relationship between the Yugoslav ideology as exhibited in Serbian music magazines published between the two world wars. These are the following journals: Music (1928–1929), Bulletin of the Music Society „Stanković” (1928–1934, 1938–1941; in January 1931 it was renamed The Musical Gazette), The Sound (1932–1936), Herald of the South Slavic Choral Union (1935–1936, 1938), Slavic music (1939–1941) and Review of Music (1940). I have excluded the magazine Musical Gazette (1922) from consideration because I have already discussed its ideological aspects in an earlier article (2009). Yugoslav topics in interwar music periodicals are addressed in an ecstatic tone by the music writers and editors (particularly immediately after the foundation of the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes); one also observes open dissent and criticism of undesirable, wasted tendencies. Signs of profound differences with respect to the fundamental aspect of Yugoslav ideology – i.e. on the question of the nature and degree of the unity of nations under the auspices of the ideology, appeared relatively early in these journals. I argue that three elements: open enthusiasm, criticism/polemic and fundamental differences, constituted a framework within which the Yugoslav ideology was expressed in the Serbian musical periodicals. The third aspect has proved to be crucial. One could observe two different and even opposing views on the Yugoslav ideology. While some musicians strongly advocated integral Yugoslavism, others wanted the preservation of distinctive national features within this ideology. This division is illustrated by the writings of Croatian composer and ethnomusicologist Božidar Širola and Serbian composer and music critic Milenko Živković. The division in question culminated in the case of the South Slavic Choral Union, which Croatian Choral Union refused to join. Hence, Serbian music periodicals provide an insight into the fundamental ideological and political problem of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia. PB - Београд : Музиколошки институт Српске академије наука и уметности T2 - Музикологија / Musicology T1 - Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба T1 - Two Views on the Yugoslav Ideology in Serbian Music Periodicals Between the Two World Wars SP - 155 EP - 166 IS - 17 DO - 10.2298/MUZ1417155V UR - https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_dais_3871 ER -
@article{ author = "Васић, Александар", year = "2014", abstract = "Студија испитује однос према идеологији југословенства у српским музичким часописима између два светска рата. Уочено је присуство двају различитих, па и супротних ставова. Док су поједини музичари снажно заступали идеју интегралног југословенства, други су желели очување дистинктивних обележја унутар те заједнице. Та је подела кулминирала у случају Јужнословенског певачког савеза у чији састав Хрватски пјевачки савез није ушао. Тако се у српској музичкој периодици може пратити темељни идеолошки и политички проблем Краљевине Југославије., This study explores the relationship between the Yugoslav ideology as exhibited in Serbian music magazines published between the two world wars. These are the following journals: Music (1928–1929), Bulletin of the Music Society „Stanković” (1928–1934, 1938–1941; in January 1931 it was renamed The Musical Gazette), The Sound (1932–1936), Herald of the South Slavic Choral Union (1935–1936, 1938), Slavic music (1939–1941) and Review of Music (1940). I have excluded the magazine Musical Gazette (1922) from consideration because I have already discussed its ideological aspects in an earlier article (2009). Yugoslav topics in interwar music periodicals are addressed in an ecstatic tone by the music writers and editors (particularly immediately after the foundation of the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes); one also observes open dissent and criticism of undesirable, wasted tendencies. Signs of profound differences with respect to the fundamental aspect of Yugoslav ideology – i.e. on the question of the nature and degree of the unity of nations under the auspices of the ideology, appeared relatively early in these journals. I argue that three elements: open enthusiasm, criticism/polemic and fundamental differences, constituted a framework within which the Yugoslav ideology was expressed in the Serbian musical periodicals. The third aspect has proved to be crucial. One could observe two different and even opposing views on the Yugoslav ideology. While some musicians strongly advocated integral Yugoslavism, others wanted the preservation of distinctive national features within this ideology. This division is illustrated by the writings of Croatian composer and ethnomusicologist Božidar Širola and Serbian composer and music critic Milenko Živković. The division in question culminated in the case of the South Slavic Choral Union, which Croatian Choral Union refused to join. Hence, Serbian music periodicals provide an insight into the fundamental ideological and political problem of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia.", publisher = "Београд : Музиколошки институт Српске академије наука и уметности", journal = "Музикологија / Musicology", title = "Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба, Two Views on the Yugoslav Ideology in Serbian Music Periodicals Between the Two World Wars", pages = "155-166", number = "17", doi = "10.2298/MUZ1417155V", url = "https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_dais_3871" }
Васић, А.. (2014). Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба. in Музикологија / Musicology Београд : Музиколошки институт Српске академије наука и уметности.(17), 155-166. https://doi.org/10.2298/MUZ1417155V https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_dais_3871
Васић А. Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба. in Музикологија / Musicology. 2014;(17):155-166. doi:10.2298/MUZ1417155V https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_dais_3871 .
Васић, Александар, "Два погледа на југословенство у српској музичкој периодици међуратног доба" in Музикологија / Musicology, no. 17 (2014):155-166, https://doi.org/10.2298/MUZ1417155V ., https://hdl.handle.net/21.15107/rcub_dais_3871 .